If you’re planning a move—or simply trying to reclaim your space—there’s one category of clutter that can feel especially overwhelming: toys. Between birthdays, holidays, hand-me-downs, and those “just because” gifts, kids’ belongings tend to pile up fast. And if you’re downsizing but also planning to grow your family in the future, the big question becomes: what do you keep, and what can go?
Here are our favorite tips to tackle toy clutter the smart (and sentimental) way:
- Start with a Purpose
Before you begin, get clear on your goal. Are you trying to fit everything into a smaller home? Or just create a more organized play area? If more kids are on the horizon, you’ll want to save the best, most timeless toys—while still freeing up space now.
- Sort into 3 Categories
Make three piles:
- Keep for future kids
- Donate or give away
- Trash or recycle (for broken or incomplete items)
Ask yourself:
- Is it in good condition?
- Is it age-neutral or timeless?
- Does it have sentimental value?
- Does it take up too much space compared to how much it’s played with?
- Store the “Keepers” Wisely
Save only the essentials. Focus on quality over quantity—think wooden toys, puzzles, books, and pretend play items. Label storage bins clearly by age or category and keep them in a dry, pest-free place like a closet or labeled plastic tubs in a basement (off the floor). - Involve Your Kids (If Age Appropriate)
Letting kids choose a few toys to donate helps them understand generosity and gives them a sense of control. They might surprise you with what they’re willing to part with. - Donate with Intention
There are many wonderful organizations that would love your gently used toys. Consider donating to:
- Goodwill
- Salvation Army
- Local women’s shelters
- Children’s hospitals (check rules first)
- Daycares or preschools
- Buy Nothing Groups or Facebook Marketplace (free section)
Bonus: some places will even pick up from your home.
Downsizing Soon? Mr. Lister Can Help
Decluttering isn’t just good for your space—it’s a game-changer when it comes to listing your home. Clean, open spaces photograph better and help potential buyers picture themselves in your home.
If you’re thinking about selling or need guidance on preparing your home for a move, Mr. Lister Realty is here to help every step of the way—from listing to decluttering to saving thousands on commission.
Ready to list smart and save big? Contact Mr. Lister Realty today or visit MrListerRealty.com to get started.